Roy Keane has been outspoken in his criticism of James Maddison, particularly regarding the midfielder’s ability to help Tottenham Hotspur rise to the upper echelons of the Premier League. On The Overlap, presented by Sky Bet, Keane took aim at Maddison’s career trajectory and questioned his impact at Spurs, claiming that Maddison’s performances have often fallen short when the stakes are high.
Keane began by referencing Maddison’s early career, mentioning a moment at Tamworth, a non-league club, where Maddison was taken off during a game. “We saw Maddison at Tamworth, he was taken off. Tamworth are non-league,” Keane remarked, adding that he doesn’t believe Maddison has the consistency or temperament to take Tottenham to the next level. He continued, “People say Maddison’s the man. When is he going to step up to the plate? He got relegated with Leicester and he’ll get relegated with Spurs.”
Despite Maddison’s talent, Keane remains unconvinced about his ability to lead a team like Spurs back into the top six. “Maddison isn’t bad when he’s not at the darts,” Keane said, referencing a time when Maddison, along with his teammate Brennan Johnson, was spotted at the World Darts Championship in December, just hours after Spurs had played out a disappointing 2-2 draw against relegation-threatened Wolves. Keane clearly believes that Maddison’s off-field distractions may be a reflection of his overall mentality.
Keane’s harsh words didn’t end there. He questioned whether Maddison could truly inspire his Spurs teammates in the dressing room: “If you’re a player in the Spurs dressing room and Maddison’s back in the squad, you wouldn’t be looking and going ‘oh Jesus – he’s back today. We’re going to be fine.’” His comment reflects the idea that, despite Maddison’s talent, he may not be the type of leader who can galvanize a struggling team.
Keane also took aim at Maddison’s international standing, noting that despite England’s vast pool of talent, Maddison has consistently found himself on the periphery of Gareth Southgate’s squad: “England have a squad of 300 and he can’t even get in that.” Keane suggested that many fans are perhaps overestimating Maddison’s ability and that he may not be the game-changing player some believe he is.
While Keane’s remarks were harsh, Maddison’s recent performances for Tottenham have certainly shown his potential. He scored a crucial goal against Manchester United, helping Spurs secure a vital 1-0 victory. This goal, along with his tally of 10 goals and 6 assists across all competitions this season, has underscored his value to Spurs in what has otherwise been a challenging campaign.
However, despite Maddison’s contributions on the pitch, his season has not been without its criticisms. As mentioned earlier, his trip to the Darts Championship after the Wolves draw did not go unnoticed, with some fans taking issue with the timing of the outing, given the team’s disappointing result. This incident contributed to the perception that Maddison might not always be fully focused on the task at hand.
Despite this, Maddison’s ability to produce on the field remains undeniable. His creativity and vision have been key for Spurs, and his individual contributions have been vital in some of their stronger performances this season. But as Keane’s comments highlight, there are questions about whether Maddison can consistently lead Spurs to greater success, especially given the club’s ongoing struggles.
For Maddison, his challenge will be to prove his critics wrong and show that he has what it takes to carry Spurs to the next level. If he can maintain his performances and play a pivotal role in helping Spurs finish higher in the Premier League standings, he may eventually silence some of the doubters. But for now, as Keane has pointed out, the jury is still out on whether Maddison can truly be the difference-maker at a club with such lofty aspirations.
Leave a Reply